April 13, 2024

Is AT&T or Xfinity web higher?

A case may very well be made for both supplier as the most effective total, however given the selection of AT&T Fiber or Xfinity, I might advocate AT&T Fiber. Xfinity has a bigger protection space and decrease introductory charges, however AT&T Fiber comes with no information caps, tools charges, contracts or set value will increase. Xfinity, then again, is more likely to include some or all of these situations relying on the place you reside and the plan you select.

AT&T and Xfinity are two of the biggest web service suppliers within the US, so one or each suppliers could also be out there at your deal with. If that is the case, you will have a pleasant collection of high-speed, high-value plans.

The quick speeds, honest pricing, and favorable service phrases have earned each suppliers excessive buyer satisfaction scores. AT&T and Xfinity completed with above-average scores amongst main web suppliers in the newest surveys from the American Buyer Satisfaction Index and J.D. Energy and Associates.

Which of those two ISPs, AT&T or Xfinity most closely fits your own home networking wants? Let’s intently look at how they stack up so you possibly can determine. 

Product image Product image

Our take – AT&T fiber plans are powerful to beat: 300Mbps beginning at $55 per thirty days, 500Mbps for $65 and gigabit service beginning at simply $80 month-to-month. On high of that, over 100 AT&T cities nationwide are eligible for the corporate’s quickest fiber plans: 2Gbps for $125 and 5Gbps for $225.

Or name to study extra: (855) 900-7736

Verify with AT&T

Product image Product image

Our take – Xfinity gives extra plan choices than AT&T and is more likely to have the most cost effective plan, although speeds with the mentioned plan shall be a lot decrease than the lowest-priced AT&T Fiber plan. Simply be careful for a value enhance after your promotional interval of 1 or two years — it might add as a lot as $20 to $50 to your invoice, relying on the place you reside and the plan you select.

Or name to study extra: (844) 577-0451

Verify with Xfinity

AT&T vs. Xfinity plans, pricing and speeds

You will discover an outline of AT&T Fiber and Xfinity web plans beneath. Out there Xfinity speeds, pricing and repair phrases can and do fluctuate by area and the precise plan you select. I solely included plan particulars for AT&T Fiber as a result of in case your selection comes right down to Xfinity and AT&T’s DSL or mounted wi-fi service, you must go along with Xfinity.

AT&T Fiber plans

AT&T Fiber plan
Learn full overview
Beginning month-to-month value Max obtain speeds Max add speeds Tools payment Knowledge cap Contract
Fiber 300 $55 300Mbps 300Mbps None None None
Fiber 500 $65 500Mbps 500Mbps None None None
Fiber Gig $80 1,000Mbps 1,000Mbps None None None
Fiber 2 Gig $125 2,000Mbps 2,000Mbps None None None
Fiber 5 Gig $225 5,000Mbps 5,000Mbps None None None

Present extra (1 merchandise)

Xfinity web plans

Xfinity plan
Learn full overview
Beginning month-to-month value Max obtain speeds Max add speeds Tools payment Knowledge cap Contract
Join $20 150Mbps 10Mbps $15 (non-obligatory) 1.25TB 1-2 years (non-obligatory)
Join Extra $35 300Mbps 10Mbps $15 (non-obligatory) 1.25TB 1-2 years (non-obligatory)
Quick $55 500Mbps 15Mbps $15 (non-obligatory) 1.25TB 1-2 years (non-obligatory)
Superfast $70 800Mbps 15Mbps $15 (non-obligatory) 1.25TB 1-2 years (non-obligatory)
Gigabit $80 1,000Mbps 35Mbps $15 (non-obligatory) 1.25TB 1-2 years (non-obligatory)
Gigabit Further $85 1,200Mbps 35Mbps $15 (non-obligatory) 1.25TB 1-2 years (non-obligatory)
Gigabit x2 $100 2,000Mbps 200Mbps $15 (non-obligatory) None 1-2 years (non-obligatory)

Present extra (3 gadgets)

Xfinity’s pace tiers are pretty constant all through all service areas, however pricing might fluctuate barely from one market to the subsequent. For instance, the usual pace for Xfinity Join is 150Mbps, however the beginning value can fluctuate wherever from $20 to $30 per thirty days based mostly on the place you reside.

Charges on all plans, excluding the $300-per-month 10 gigabit plan, are set to extend after the primary yr or two of service, relying in your location and the plan you select. The precise enhance will, once more, fluctuate by location and the plan you select, but it surely’s doable your month-to-month invoice might go up by $20 to $50 or extra as soon as the value assure expires. Service phrases additionally fluctuate by location and plan as an information cap, tools payment (in case you select to lease) and contract might apply.

In the meantime, AT&T Fiber plans, speeds and phrases are constant no matter what a part of the nation you reside in. The supplier’s 300, 500 and 1,000Mbps plans can be found in all service areas whereas many may also have the selection of two,000 and 5,000Mbps plans as nicely. There isn’t any set value enhance after 12 months.

AT&T plans do not include service contracts, however your invoice will go up after the promo interval if in case you have DSL or mounted wi-fi. Not one of the plans will soar by greater than $15, although, so the rise is not as steep as you would possibly see with Xfinity.

Charges, information caps and different potential sticking factors

Each suppliers might tack on taxes and month-to-month charges every month, and in some circumstances, you will additionally must handle an information cap.

AT&T vs. Xfinity added charges

First, the charges. Like most suppliers, AT&T and Xfinity will cost you a bit further every month in case you do not enroll in autopay or paperless billing, however these charges are simple sufficient to dodge. Simply, you understand, enroll in autopay and paperless billing. Drawback solved.

Comcast's xFi gateway sitting on top of a table Comcast's xFi gateway sitting on top of a table

You will want so as to add $14 per thirty days to your Comcast invoice to make use of its xFi Gateway — however you possibly can skip that payment by utilizing your individual modem and router. 

Comcast

The tools charges are one other story. With AT&T, you will not must pay further to make use of AT&T’s Wi-Fi gateway. That is included within the common month-to-month payment. With Comcast Xfinity, the associated fee to lease the xFi Gateway is $15 per thirty days, however it could be included at no further cost together with your plan. You may also bypass the payment, if there’s one, by utilizing your individual tools, offered it is accredited to work with Xfinity, and also you’re OK with the truth that Comcast will not be capable to provide device-specific technical assist.

AT&T vs. Xfinity information caps

As for information caps, AT&T does not use them with any of its fiber plans, so we’ll give it some credit score. There’s, nonetheless, an information cap for AT&T’s nonfiber plans, which is why we mentioned just a bit little bit of credit score.

AT&T Web, the DSL aspect of the service, comes with an information cap of terabyte and a half of information (1.5TB) in a given month of service. You will get charged $10 for each further 50GB of information your own home makes use of. That further cost will get capped at $100, so as soon as you have eaten up at the least 500GB of additional information, AT&T throws its fingers up and says, “see you subsequent month.” Should you suppose you want limitless information, you possibly can improve your plan for an additional $30 per thirty days to sidestep the info cap altogether, and you may also ditch the info cap by bundling dwelling web with different AT&T providers.

One other level of observe: The information cap with AT&T Fastened Wi-fi is way decrease, kicking in at 300GB. You will nonetheless get charged $10 for every further 50GB of information you employ, however AT&T caps the cost at $200 as an alternative of $100. Be conscious of falling asleep throughout a Netflix binge, AT&T Fastened Wi-fi clients.

Xfinity, in the meantime, enforces an information cap of 1.25TB per thirty days, however some areas and plans might haven’t any information cap in any respect. In case you have a cap, going over might price you $10 for each 50GB of extra information used, capped at $100.

In equity, 1.25TB is lots of information, but it surely’s not unreasonable to suppose {that a} busy family would sometimes want extra. For instance, on my community, the place I earn a living from home, stream loads of films in 4K, and dwell with a roommate who’s on-line simply as a lot as I’m, we went by way of about 320GB of information right here within the first 9 days of the month. That put us on tempo to make use of simply over 1TB by the tip of the month.

Should you dwell with, say, two roommates — or with a complete household of web customers — then information caps like these is likely to be one thing you’d need to avoid in case you might.

AT&T vs. Xfinity contracts

AT&T web service, from fiber to mounted wi-fi, doesn’t require a contract. Xfinity additionally doesn’t make you signal a contract, however choose plans might require a one- or two-year time period settlement in an effort to get the bottom pricing. Canceling or altering your service earlier than the time period settlement is up might end in early termination charges and shedding the decrease introductory price on service.

AT&T vs. Xfinity set up prices

AT&T prices $99 for skilled, in-home set up, however self-installation kits can be found in some circumstances, too. Verify with the corporate to see if that is an possibility for you. If not, asking the salesperson if they’re going to waive the set up payment might be definitely worth the try, as AT&T typically waives it throughout seasonal promos.

With Xfinity, skilled set up prices much less at $40, and you do not have to “qualify” for the self-installation possibility such as you do with AT&T. Level Comcast.

AT&T vs. Xfinity protection in contrast

Screenshot of FCC map displaying AT&T and Xfinity coverage areas. Screenshot of FCC map displaying AT&T and Xfinity coverage areas.

AT&T’s networks (copper in pink, fiber in purple) and Xfinity’s cable web service (inexperienced) share protection areas within the South, Midwest and elements of California.

FCC/Mapbox

A product of the nation’s largest cable supplier, Xfinity Web, is accessible in choose areas throughout 39 states and Washington, DC, protecting about one-third of the whole inhabitants of the US. Most of that protection is cable web, however Xfinity has a small fiber community.

Areas the place Xfinity’s fiber web service is accessible primarily embrace elements Indiana, Illinois and Michigan, although elements of Florida, Georgia and Tennessee could also be serviceable for fiber as nicely.

As for AT&T, the telecom firm gives dwelling web plans in 21 states, protecting a lot of the South, Midwest, and West Coast. Each suppliers could also be out there at your deal with in some elements of the nation, together with Atlanta, Chicago, Detroit, Houston, Memphis, Miami and San Francisco.

AT&T pegs the variety of households with entry to fiber at roughly 21 million, spanning over 100 metro areas. The corporate plans to broaden fiber entry to tens of millions extra properties by the tip of 2025, together with the rollout of its multigigabit plans.

For the remainder, there’s AT&T Web Air and AT&T Fastened Wi-fi, which use a satellite tv for pc mounted at your own home to obtain a wi-fi sign, and AT&T Web, which makes use of DSL copper cable connections together with the corporate’s fiber infrastructure to ship service to individuals’s properties, albeit it at a lot slower speeds.

AT&T vs. Xfinity buyer satisfaction scores

ACSI rankings for US customer satisfaction with internet service providers ACSI rankings for US customer satisfaction with internet service providers

AT&T and Comcast Xfinity each do nicely for buyer satisfaction amongst web suppliers.

ACSI

Everybody likes to hate their web supplier, so it is no shock that buyer satisfaction scores for the ISP business aren’t something spectacular. Nonetheless, AT&T and Comcast Xfinity are comparatively sturdy performers right here. Every completed with an above-average rating from the American Buyer Satisfaction Index in 2023, ok to position each among the many high 4 of all ISPs surveyed.

In the meantime, AT&T grabbed the highest spot within the North-Central and West areas, and second within the South (the place Google Fiber scored highest) in the newest J.D. Energy US Residential Web Service Supplier Satisfaction Examine for 2023. Xfinity buyer satisfaction was beneath AT&T in every of these three areas, however nonetheless comfortably above the regional averages.

AT&T vs. Xfinity recap

In case your choices are AT&T Web (the copper-based, DSL-related service) or AT&T’s mounted wi-fi service and Xfinity, the latter would be the best option for pace, worth, reliability, and many others., practically each time. Alternatively, in case your deal with is serviceable for AT&T Fiber and Xfinity, you are more likely to get a greater worth with extra favorable service phrases from AT&T Fiber than Xfinity. Given the selection of the 2, Xfinity stands out for its broad availability and low introductory pricing, however AT&T Fiber has the benefit in just about each different class.

AT&T vs. Xfinity FAQs

Which is healthier, AT&T or Xfinity?

It is determined by the way you choose “higher.” Xfinity has the quickest plan between the 2 (the Gigabit Professional plan at 10,000Mbps), however at $300 per thirty days, it is also the costliest. AT&T has a 5,000Mbps plan that is a bit cheaper at $225 a month. We’d lean in direction of AT&T due to its fiber web plans, however these aren’t out there to all clients inside its footprint. Others might need to accept DSL. In these circumstances, Xfinity and its cable web plans could be preferable. 


Present extra

Is Xfinity cheaper than AT&T?

Amongst their common choices, Xfinity’s least expensive plan, relying on the place you reside, ranges from $20-$30 per thirty days, whereas AT&T Fiber’s least expensive tier begins at $55 month-to-month. Nevertheless, each suppliers additionally provide discounted plans for low-income households. Entry from AT&T incorporates a 100Mbps plan for $30 per thirty days, whereas Xfinity has Web Necessities, a 50Mbps plan for $10 a month.


Present extra

Are you able to get fiber web service from AT&T or Xfinity?

Sure. AT&T’s fiber web choices are extra broadly out there. Per the FCC’s newest data, AT&T supplies fiber web to a few third of its clients. In the meantime, Xfinity is usually a hybrid of cable and fiber, although its Gigabit Professional tier is a 100% fiber connection.


Present extra